27 Comments
User's avatar
Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

It’s why I favour Mutual Equity and employee ownership . There are millions of companies where the founder wants to retire , so let’s use this ‘silver tsunami’ to encourage employee ownership. The workers then become the shareholders.

Grace Blakeley's avatar

Love the idea of employee ownership - the right of employees to come together and buy a business when the owner moves on would be brilliant

Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

Yes. I see it as part of a fairer ‘asset owning democracy ‘ . Rather than nationalise , we mutualise as its direct ownership and shared wealth more broadly. I don’t know why the Labour & Cooperative party is not promoting this ? ‘ Thatcher wanted you to own your own house, we want you to own your business’ .

Works for Arup, Go Ape, Pa Consulting, Aardman Animations , Riverford Organic Farms , Foster Architects, John Lewis , Richer Sounds and many more .

Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

It’s been talked about for the Post Office. Can’t see why it can’t work regionally for water companies ( EOT hybrids owned by employees and customers) , train companies, care homes, childcare, NHS? It’s already ours… why did we let the Vulture Capitalists take control and lease it back to us.

Godfrey Moase's avatar

This can work. The Employee Ownership Trust model (where it’s more than a minority stakeholder fig leaf) can work in this regard.

Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

Yes. This is my point 🙏

Godfrey Moase's avatar

Labour Managed Firms are definitely an important model but given how difficult it is to access capital and start such a firm (relative to conventional enterprises) it will still require a degree of grunt organising work to open up space for this model (of which I am a massive fan).

Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

You’ll be surprised by the options that exist that don’t require large capital upfront . It all depends on the objectives of the owner.

They even get to sell their business tax free!

Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

I have a pension called a SSAS. Effectively, I am the Trustee of my own money , so I lent it to my friends and it’s used to provide supported living …..not paying fees to the City.

Take this principle and apply it to the £5bn pension fund of John Lewis. Why can’t they use their own pension in an employee owned company. Instead they borrowed £500Bn.

Apply to the £400bn Council Pension Fund. I can help you build your own homes and provide affordable housing or rental .

It’s not rocket science yet we have been brainwashed to think we have to use the system and pay for the privilege??

Godfrey Moase's avatar

In coincidental news, my next post is actually on worker ownership and its benefits.

Richard Perry MA FRSA's avatar

I’m talking about established companies. KKR invented private equity and even they are taking small steps towards it.

Godfrey Moase's avatar

Great article Grace. I wonder if part of the issue going on here is that underlying the situation in the UK and the US is the relative stagnation/loss of position of these domestic economies within the broader global market. From a distance, it feels like capitalist classes in each nation are engaging in class warfare, in part, to maintain their own relative positions through the further immiseration of their respecting working classes but this is on the back of the neoliberal turn.

It would certainly explain how Australia, in being more directly connected to the Chinese market, is partially shielded (at least for now) from this dynamic.

Grace Blakeley's avatar

Yes I've written about how the trade war is based on preserving US imperialism by fighting Chinese technological supremacy here: https://substack.com/@graceblakeley/p-164545632

Miffsky.'s avatar

"...economists tend to assume that wages reflect productivity over the long run. They argue that workers’ remuneration reflects the value they add to the production process. In the short run, they think wages fluctuate based on supply of and demand for labour. When unemployment is low and the economy is growing, the assumption is that wages will rise as employers bid to attract scarce workers. Unsurprisingly, this is not how things work in the real world."

Indeed: and deconstructing and superseding this mainstream economic mumbo-jumbo is THE urgent imperative if we are to reverse this current drift towards political barbarity.

Many thanks always for all of these invaluable insights, Grace! 😊👍

Yuanjun Zheng 郑远均's avatar

I totally agree with Grace’s conclusions. We truly live in a volatile and perilous time. 20th century has been coined by eminent historian Eric Hobsbawn as the age of extremes. The current world order seems to be more extreme than the previous decade. We should be bracing for the worst. Don’t yield to the whimsical autocrats and oligarchs. And think about strategies to unite ,make rallying cries and fight for collective futures and dignities.

Dominic Ahern's avatar

Anecdotally, have had quite a few conversations with companies looking to adopt more AI tools to try and do more for less. Lowering of the NI threshold this year also had a bit of a chilling effect on hiring, and probably disproportionately impacted businesses using part time workers (like hospitality) who’s NI burden would have been much lower before. More companies requiring working from office now, at least hybrid, and reversing trend of pure remote working making harder for employees to move roles. And let’s not forget the +1m indefinitely trapped in unsaleable homes post Grenfell who might find it harder to move jobs …

Grace Blakeley's avatar

Yep - firms are using AI and tax changes as pretexts to squeeze labour costs, while housing market dysfunction and the retreat from remote work are trapping people in place. It’s all playing in to the reassertino of employer power post-pandemic. See, e.g. https://www.ft.com/content/605b329f-622c-4307-ba50-29895a2b29a1

Dominic Ahern's avatar

The extent to which these are pretexts may vary. There are genuine financial pressures on companies too. We've seen many take on large amounts of debt through covid to carry on and still see an impact of that. I was also surprised how many companies absorbed all additional costs under the IR35 reforms rather than sharing the burden with their workers. And I would argue the recent NI rises have had a real impact rather than purely a narrative one. Companies are not immune from inflationary pressures, particularly if you look at price sensitive consumer businesses. Early stage tech find harder to raise funds to support new jobs and wage growth, valuations have dropped off, and LSE listings a tiny fraction of what they have been. The truth is, whilst there may be bad corporate actors, this mess is a making of the state and global factors too.

Simon C's avatar

“leaving workers to deal with the consequences of a crisis they played no part in causing.” Really? All those proto-Reform voters just gagging to give power to Farage? The same all-too-easily duped fools who went along with, voted for Brexit? The same imbeciles who see the problem as immigrants stealing their services rather than Nigel and Boris’s mates? Really? They may be dupes but they ain’t innocent.

Grace Blakeley's avatar

I've written about why this attitude is profoundly misguided here: https://substack.com/@graceblakeley/p-174002188

Simon C's avatar

Don’t disagree with most of your analysis. However since Thatcher, particularly since the crash, we are where we are… the happy idea that we can “show people that there is another option… to come together in their communities, in their workplaces, and on the streets to take on the people who are really in charge: the billionaires and the politicians in their pockets” is vastly over optimistic. This is not the brave working class of 1945, emerging from a bitterly hard-fought conflict and inter war years of Tory oppression to kick out Churchill and usher in the welfare state, the NHS, nationalised assets. This is a working class in name only, influenced by social media diversion, soporific TV, celebrity trivia, taking out their understandable disappointments on “the woke”, the Labour government, “lefties” etc. the idea that this ill-educated, misinformed, easily dupable, fragmentary “grouping” can be moulded (certainly not mould itself) into a cohesive anti-right, anti-oligarch, anti-fascist bulwark is frankly nuts. The best bet? Sad to say it may take the coming to power of some form of ultra-right government like Farage - which is bound to crash against the self same rocks of economic failure - to show “the people” that real, radical, socialised alternatives are the only way forward.

Miffsky.'s avatar

“65 percent of high-income consumers plan to spend the same or more compared to last year, while this figure drops to 56 percent for middle-income shoppers and just 48 percent for those in lower-income brackets.”

Given that the "lower income brackets" include those of we in the ever-burgeoning "skid row economic consort"; then there is little if any change in our model of economic activity when we are perpetually spending every single penny last year, this year, next year, and all entirely on subsisting. Our spending imperatives thus fail to be influenced by this concept of "Consumer Confidence", or perhaps more correctly: its absence, given the reactive immediacy of our fiscal calculations.

Thanks again, in solidarity, Grace! 😊👍

Donavon Price's avatar

Spot on! The situation in the U.S. is even worse since health care costs are such a significant cost for Americans. Most working Americans get health care insurance through their employer and often only realize how much of their compensation goes to their health insurance premiums when they get sick and no longer work. In 2025, the average single coverage was $9,325 USD with the employee picking up $2,467 of the bill. There is a projected 6.5%increase in employer sponsored health insurance in the U.S., which means a $606 increase in annual compensation for a typical American worker based of the $6,850 picked up by the boss. The $606 raise will never be noticed by the employe since it was part of a negotiated price between the company (employer) and insurance company and never shows up in paychecks. The largest employers have the lowest health insurance costs (per employee) which provides them with a competitive advantage over smaller firms. This is a circular reinforcing model that provides the largest employers in the U.S. to have the smallest health care premium costs which keeps people enslaved if they or a family member has a costly medical condition. These life and death costs are real to ordinary working people verses the abstract macro-economic data like GDP or CPI statistics that get repeated monthly in the news.

Brian Edmunds's avatar

Great observation Grace. I don’t think workers are any different to the rest. We all see a train wreck coming and it ain’t hidden. We are all under pressure to spend our money on just survival. It’s been that way and getting worse for some years. Pre the crash even. It’s a crumbling society in every way. The problem isn’t unseen Grace. Everyone knows it’s a crash of some description coming. France today, are facing similar. No one has an answer. Except me. Socialist in part and democratic for sure. Capitalism has been a loose canon gathering speed down hill into the abyss. And it’s more or less going to happen. We are all struggling to find extra money to enjoy. So that’s why we are all unhappy. There is just more austerity and cuts with rising prices costs and inflation whilst we have stagnant wages. The newer is nowhere on the horizon. And those charged with repairing it are clueless. We see it all. Yes, companies can become cooperative or worker run but that communist ideology is debunked. Nothing up to now has worked . And likely never will. We allow the rich to be wealthy in asset and hold the vast majority of money. It’s not in our economy. Vast amounts are not here. Money is abroad. That’s the problem. We are and the government is devoid of it and do underfunded. We need all or most of it moving all the time! This creates business, work and wages. Spending moves money freely without debt and interest attached. So spending and earning well making profit and paying lots more taxes are where we need to be. But money not spent produces no income no business and no wages. It brings in no tax. So there is no other way. We have to change our framework if money. We did it for decimalisation. We need to reinstate exchange controls to keep all sterling in the uk. We need to swap present money for a new digital money. Add a spend by date to that digital money to make it move all the time forever! We will never be short of money again. Spend it or get it taken by the government. Spend it or don’t, up to you. But we need money in our economy not abroad, moving. Around us to girl the economic growth. That’s my way. But by all means give your ideas? Make as much as you can. That’s the way to get you out of bed. Make working pay do well those on benefits have a real choice. Especially if jobs are in abundance. Where there is money being spent you have an economy.

Grace Blakeley's avatar

Yes it's clear to most people what's going on - wages have stagnated, prices have soared, and the system is running on fumes. I agree that we need a fundamental reset of how the economy works: one that prioritises collective wellbeing over private profit, keeps wealth circulating rather than hoarded, and gives working people real power over production and investment. Without that, we’re just managing decline.

Brian Edmunds's avatar

I completely agree Grace. Tax is a way of government gaining income. Is people need money to be spent with us all to gain our incomes. Most taxation bypasses us and goes straight to the exchequer. But most businesses and self employed need SPENDING of money to gain their/our income. That fact is lost on most people. Money needs to pass and change hands for both revenue and tax revenue to work. Government has tax we have Spending. Rose facts need to be remembered to understand an economy. Wealth is snd should be the assets, services and goods bought with money from SPENDING. Money itself has to flow around to give that wealth. Money itself should be used as an exchange of work. A fair exchange of work, yours for mine. SPENDING ensures that fair exchange. But when money isn’t SPENT it’s not fair or exchanged. And that impasse is the cause of stagnation. Money unspent triggers no tax not ties it enter our economy from SPENDING. So the whole system fails at that point, because we/the government allow it! That’s my point Grace. It can easily be changed to ensure money moves around us all. Steve Baker and others like Liam Halligan Matt Goodwin etc, keep saying that we can’t afford welfare or pensions do inside cuts are the answer, they are so wrong Grace. We can’t afford welfare gain do much more if money is SPENT more often and in greater weight by those who hold it and have too much of it. We could increase the yearly tax take from its present £1.1 Trillion pounds. To £4 trillion pounds per year easily if money is not wealth but the exchange of work it’s supposed to be. The loop of tax Ed straight to government does nothing for our daily economy. Whereas normal spending gives us all the feel and taste of it even for a little time. Money shouldn’t stop moving. It’s when it ties, by those who hold on to it are the blame for our lot!